Base Period Nutrition
One of the common objectives of the Base period is to improve aerobic endurance. There are many physiological benefits your body realizes as your aerobic endurance improves, such as an increase in muscle capillaries, greater heart pumping capacity and more plentiful muscle enzymes for converting fat to energy. Related to this last benefit is your body’s greater preference for using fat for fuel while sparing glycogen as aerobic endurance improves. This is an important change because it means a greater reliance on a fuel source each of us has plenty of – fat. Regardless of how skinny you are you have enough body fat stored to fuel many days of continuous exercise. The problem is accessing it.
If you were to stop training for a few weeks your body would begin to lose its taste for fat. It would, instead, gradually shift toward a preference for using carbohydrate, a sugar compound stored in the body as glycogen and glucose, to fuel exercise. So that after this time off, as you started exercising again, most of the energy used in your workouts would come from glycogen and glucose. And your body would not be very good at accessing its fat for fuel. That’s a problem. It means that you will need to continually feed your body sugar from sports drinks, bars, gels and other sources during workouts since you don't have much stored away. There’s a limit as to how much sugar your gut can process during exercise. So you face the double-headed problem of not being able to take in enough sugar to fuel your engine while beginning to slow your pace despite what feels like a high effort. This is an early stage of “bonking.”
In the Base period, assuming it comes on the heels of having had a break from high volume training, it will take your body many weeks of long, aerobic endurance workouts to train it to once again preferentially use fat for fuel. It will have slowly shifted to a preference for sugar. And the more sugar you feed it, the more it will want. In a winter Base period, the holiday season, with all of its pastries and sweets, may have compounded this shift. You want – actually, you need – to speed up the fueling changes your body goes through as you begin to increase the duration of your workouts. What you eat now plays a role in this change.
The body uses for fuel whatever it is given the most of. If you eat a diet high in carbohydrate, which at some times in the year is necessary (more on that at another time), it will prefer to use sugar for fuel. If you feed it more fat while reducing carbohydrate it will learn to use fat for fuel. That’s a good thing since it augments your aerobic endurance training.
I know what you must be thinking now: Eating fat is bad for your health. That’s an idea which grew out of the 1950s and refuses to go away. Like many “old wives’ tales” there is an element of truth to it. Some types of fat are definitely bad for your health and should be avoided. The worst is hydrogenated fat, often referred to as “trans fat.” This is a fat that nutrition science gave us as a gift 60-some years ago to avoid what they saw as a problem – too much saturated fat in our diets in the form of butter and as an ingredient in many processed foods. As is often the case, the scientific solution was eventually discovered to be worse than the original problem. Trans fat proved to be a better way to cause heart disease than saturated fat. Avoid trans fat. The label of foods that contain it will list it in the ingredients as a “partially hydrogenated” oil. Keep these foods out of your body. You’ll find them in some breads and most snack foods. Read the labels before purchasing.
The “good” fats are found in such foods as walnuts, macadamia nuts, avocado, fish, shellfish, flaxseed oil, olive oil, canola oil and the meats of range-fed animals and wild game. In the Base period slightly increase your consumption of these foods while slightly decreasing your intake of sugar and starchy foods. In this latter category are foods such as bread, bagels, cereal, corn, rice and potatoes. These are best eaten immediately following long workouts to speed recovery. Don’t make the mistake I often come across with some athletes who become so focused on avoiding starch and sugar that they shy away from them following exhaustive workouts. That’s a big mistake. We want to slightly shift your diet toward fat and away from carbohydrate during the Base period. Do not entirely avoid these foods.
By the way, it’s alright to “cheat” on your diet. In fact, you should. Having a small dessert after a meal will not have negative consequences for performance and may do wonders for your peace of mind. My favorite is gourmet, double-chocolate cookies. On days that I workout I’ll have one or two of them for dessert after dinner. Having an occasional baked potato or infrequent pasta side dish is also OK. What we’re trying to avoid in the Base period is a diet dependent on moderate- to high-glycemic carbohydrate foods while emphasizing fat. This dietary shift will contribute to your aerobic endurance fitness.
Labels: aerobic endurance, diet, fat
41 Comments:
Have you read Bob Seebohar's book, Metabolic Efficiency Training. Bob puts some specific science behind the aerobic fat burning theory by suggesting a metabolic efficiency test to determine the training point (watts) at which the fuel source shifts the balance from fat to glucose.
Joe,
Can you address theory around ideal body fat % for cyclists. I am getting conflicting comentary surounding how low we should try and go.
Great article Joe and I appreciate your insight. Interesting to learn how we train our bodies to burn fat fuels vs. carb. Are these the only 2 types of fuel our bodies can burn?
Great article and thank you for sharing insight about how our bodies learn to burn fat fuel vs. carbo fuel. Are there any other types of fuel that we burn or just these two?
Do you have any suggestions for staple foods that are not sugary/starchy? I almost always eat something starchy for breakfast (mostly bagels or cereal) and as a side with dinner (corn, rice, potatoes), but I would like to find some tasty alternatives.
putelis--I wish I could give you a number for this but there is no such thing. Too many 'it depends.' Are you 23 racing pro, 63 doing centuries, or something in between? And that doesn't even get into genetics which would be the bigger issue. And even if I could give you a number once I knew all of this it would then come down to how your body comp was determined. So I'm afraid it's just not possible.
shark--You need to experiment with other vegs and fruits. We tend to eat the same 6-8 foods all of the time. Walk through the produce dept and pick out some things you've eaten before. you may find some things you like you didn't even know existed. For example, instead of spaghetti, try spaghetti squash for a change.
All good stuff to know 'cause I have been craving avocado, nut meats and ham/bison/etc.
Funny how the body "knows" what it needs after a hard training period!
Shark - re:alt. starchy choice. Better than a bagel or white rice -try quinoa with sliced almonds or ground flaxseed and add blueberries for breakfast or make it into a pilaf (add vegs) as a side dish. Bob's Red Mill brand has a tasty one.
Joe,
I've read the paleo diet for athletes - a few times, but I am not convinced that canola oil is worth putting into our bodies. First, it is hardly paleo. Second, although it has omega-3's and is high in mono-unsaturated fat, it is *very* (chemically) processed, possibly as much as the evil oils: vegetable, corn and soybean. While a deodorization process may be "good" to make it edible and safe, deodorization process is hardly appetizing.
Why do you still recommend it, when there are much better alternatives that are much, much better than canola oil?
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
Ryan--Thanks for your note. I recommend canola because Dr. Loren Cordain who is considered the world's leading authority on Paleo eating recommends it. You might try asking him.
Joe,
When you first started using the Paleo style of eating, did it take long for your body to adjust? I have found my gut has slowed right down, nearly stopped since I have started eating Paleo style.
Sam, Australia.
Joe- question about refueling after a workout. Are HR monitors good estimates of calories burned for a workout? I would imagine they calculate the number of calories burned based on your HR zones and time spent in them, but I can't imagine they'd be terribly accurate... Thanks.
brown--It took me 2-3 weeks to start feeling normal again.
ethan--I've never seen anything that examined that issue. i suspect they are off a good bit but not sure which way. Probably varies by model. The most important thing tho is that they are reliable from one workout to the next, much like your bathroom scales.
Tony--The body also uses protein for fuel under certain conditions. but this is quite minor compared with fat and carb.
Joe, where do you stand on coconut oil? I've heard mixed things about it.
Joe-- I am a 42 year old male. I ran 13 miles today in 1:56 (here in Phx). My weight before was 199 and after was 193. During the run I drank 12 oz gatorade and 12 oz water along with 2 gel packs. Is this normal to lose that much water weight?
interesting...
as an athlete with type 1 diabetes, I have noticed that when I start a new activity/exercise, or significantly increase my intensity/volume, I will have a lot more low blood sugar, and will need to reduce my insulin. This effect subsides over time, although not entirely, if the new level of activity is maintained. I assumed that it was related to my efficiency in the activity but it also makes sense with respect to the body using more glucose initially and then gradually adapting to use more fat.
I also wonder how close to the limit most people are in terms of how many cal's/hr can be absorbed by the gut. I have had to eat a serious amount of carbs to get my blood sugar up during exercise, and I don't think I hit the limit with 5 GUs in one hour. It wasn't fun though!
Cheers.
Right don at the bottom of the comments list :(
Thanks for the great read Joe. I live in Malaysia and we we have loads of fresh coconuts - chilled and with the milk ready to drink. It apparently has a high fat content - is it good for triathletes?
36, Male. foundation IM training for Western Australia.
Thanks
Denis
Hi - Joe,
Thank you for your comprehensive information on Cycling and Triathlon Trainining, its been super helpful over the last year.
What are your thoughts on protien powders vs BCAA and a wholesome diet of lean protiens, healthy fats etc?
anon--I'm not too big on supplements. My feeling is they are, essentially, highly processed foods. That means nutrients have been lost and others added. I simply don't trust science to design my food when mother nature has been doing it so well for millions of years. After all, it's nutrition science that gave us hydrogenated/trans fat thinking they were doig a wondrous thing for our health. Instead they did just the opposite. there is an increasing body of research showing that nutrients taken out of food and delivered as dietary supplements are either ineffective or downright harmful to ones health (vit E is the latest in this category). The only reason to use such products is convenience - simply because 'real' food is not available at the time. You'll be healthier and train better by avoiding as many man-made 'health-food' products as you can.
Joe,
great, timely post here. definitely time to transition the diet to season form. couple of follow up questions...whats your take on coffee & dairy?
cusetri--See my post on coffee here - http://www.trainingbible.com/joesblog/2009/07/coffee-and-competition.html. I avoid dairy.
Sefi--When it comes to the details of nutrition I rely very heavily on my co-author of The Paleo Diet for Athletes - Loren Cordain, PhD. So I forwarded your note to him. Here is his reply...
This is not a clear cut issue as it once was. Coconut oil contains high concentrations of a saturated fatty acid called lauric acid (12:0) as well as other medium chain fatty acids (8:0, 10:0) which may have therapeutic effects. Coconut oil also contains other saturated fatty acids which elevate blood cholesterol. However, elevations in blood cholesterol without chronic low level inflammation may not necessarily increase the risk for CHD. My feeling is that coconut oil in the backdrop of a modern day Paleo diet probably has few negative health implications.
Denis Oakley--Please see my reply to Stefi on the same question.
Thanks Joe. Appreciate your time and effort on this blog. It's really useful.
I have a hard training schedule because I want to be competitive in my age group (women 50-54). I run 26 miles/week, swim 5 miles and bike - avg 150 miles per week. I need to get the bike miles higher, but it's difficult to do in the winter even in Phoenix. I have gained weight during all this training and it's not all muscle. I am putting on fat, especially in my thighs and gut. I want to be strong - and lean. I will admit that I love sugar and I'm cutting back. My question is, I do use gels and drinks on the long workouts. Have I trained my body through what I eat and what I use in the workouts to totally depend on sugar, not fat, for energy? Is that why I continue to put on weight, instead of lose weight? If so, HELP! How can I change it? Thanks for your blog, I get so much useful information from reading your posts.
anon--On long workouts (>2hrs) you will probably need to use a carb/sugar source of some type. The longer the workout the more critical this becomes. During shorter workouts you don't need carbs _unless_ your diet has been inadequate in the several hours preceding the workout. This may be the case if you go for a long run immediately out of bed in the morning, esp if you had a mediocre meal the evening before. I'd suggest readin "Racing Weight" by Matt Fitzgerald. He's done a great job of discussing this topic, the best I have ever seen in a book. Highly recommend it.
Joe, thanks for running this blog. I was wondering what sort of staples are ok by your posts guidelines? Can I continue eating brown rice (gi of 50), egg fettucinni (gi of 30), wheat tortillas (30)? Are foods that are in the high range of the low category of gi (50-60) ok as the cornerstones of a decreased carb/ increased fat diet?
Mike--The point is not to try to reduce the amount of carb in your diet but to increase the quality of the food you eat. The low quality carbs (tortillas, pasta, cereal, etc) are best eaten as recovery foods after workouts. The highest quality foods are vegs, fruits and lean protein. Eat as much of these as you can. Vegs and fruits are carbs.
Hi Joe,
To get a shift towards fat as fuel, what training intensity do you recommend? Muscles store a lot of the glucose they use for fuel, do the workout need to be specific to get a shift or can XC-Skiing (modern classic Nordic skiing use mostly upper body (Not skate)) be substituted for cycling?
Cheers,
Ole.k
Joe,
From http://dolebananadiet.com/About.aspx
"Bananas contain resistant starch, which ferments in your large intestine, creating by-products (butyrates) that block conversion of some carbohydrates into fuel. A University of Colorado study found that an increase in the amount of resistant starch contained in a meal "significantly increased post-prandial lipid oxidation and therefore could decrease fat accumulation in the long run." Replacing 5.4% of ordinary carbs with resistant starch could boost fat burning by up to 30% Practically speaking that means eating two bananas in the morning could enhance fat burning all day."
What is your take on this?
Thanks for your time.
Ole.k--For HR or pace using my system, z2. For power it's z2 in Coggan system. Aerobic training needs to be specific to the sport. Much of the change is taking place in the muscles.
Larry L--Very interesting. Never saw that before.
Hi Joe,
I have looked into RS before - there are different RS types, ie uncooked potatoes or cooked then chilled pasta, unprocessed whole grains, ckd navy beans, "green" bananas" - so the key to your readers quoted study is the bananas need to be green or unripe. Also, green bananas have ~5 gms of RS, where 1/2 c cooked navy beans have twice that. I have a hard time getting my athletes to eat green bananas, navy beans or quality whole grains are much easier.
Joe,
I understand your take on starchy foods, does this "no pasta, bread, or potatoes" during the day also apply to whole-wheat pastas/breads and sweet potatoes? I was under the impression that these were healthier alternatives due to their slower rate of breakdown into sugars. Am I mistaken?
messenger--Actually, I didn't say to never eat these things. Only to eat them at appropriate times. That's the key to nutritional peridization.
Hi Joe-
I'm coming off a long off season after my Ironman and have been reading studying Paleo for Athletes... starting initial 2 weeks today. I was unclear on the importance of still using starchy carbs in pre, during and post training while eating fruits, veggies & lean meats & nuts during first 2 weeks. Do you still recommend their use during first 2 weeks of starting Paleo? Looking forward to breaking the addiction to all the carbs...
Phillip+ -- Starch is best used in the post-workout recovery period (stages 3-4 in the Paleo for Athletes book). Starch is rich in high glycemic load carbs but is relatively low (compared with non-starchy vegs) in vitamins and minerals. That makes it great for short term recovery but not for long term recovery (stage 5). Potatoes, yams and sweet potatoes are also net alkaline enhancing which may prove to be beneficial post-workout also (there's no research on this yet).
Post a Comment
<< Home